International Hospital Ranking

Statistics

We believe that statistics is crucial to understand the quality differences between the medical services of countries. Without full understanding of medical data, patients could make irrational decisions obscured by propagandas of tourist agency and hospitals.

Surgical procedure statistics are the most important source to evaluate hospitals. Data could be available if the hospitals actively promote research programs, or join in hospital associations that require the submission of past records of surgical procedures.

We shall review these statistics, and construct the database allowing the complex queries to extract treatment and symptom specific ranking of hospitals in and outside Japan. 

Data

We think the published research papers provide the most accurate information on medical services. Research publications require third party reviews, and those statistics should have higher weight. Manipulation and distorsion of data often plagues asian research institutions. We will try to eliminate any outliers or too-good-to-be-true reports without reasonable evidences. 

Ranking

Find international hospital ranking (based on the meta set of cross study) by surgical records:

  • Ranking Finder by symptoms and surgical procedures (Recommended - Our Original Research)

  • Hospital Ranking based on the data submitted to the Ministry of Health and Labor

Find best hospitals by factors other than medical considerations, or ranking given by external institutions:

  • List of External Ranking on Health Care and Medicine  

Analysis (CABG)

Our investigations of online materials suffered missing and incosistent data with the exception of statistics on coronary artery bypass graft operations (CABG). We found the survery reports of New York and California State, CQC in UK, and weekly Asahi in Japan for CABG. Data was more than sufficient to construct the upper bound of 95% confidence intervals of mortality rates to rank hospitals. 

Comparing the best hospitals in Japan and UK against the best hospitals of New York, and California, representative US hospitals had higher number of CABG surgeries, and still with low mortality rate. Despite the top position of Sakakibara Memorial Hospital second to The Trent Cardiac Centre, selected samples of US hospitals, not necessarily the best in US, had more volumes than Japanese and UK counterparts. Mercy General Hospital had 628 annual operations of CABG, against the average of 200 in UK and Japanese hospitals.

 

 

International Hospital Ranking

Cancer Adoptive Cell Immunotherapy in Japan

Cell based Immunotherapy (Autologous immune enhancement therapy) has been more frequently practised in Japan.Techniques to harvest the cells are extremely intricate and delicate processes. For the treatments to be rountinely available to the cancer patients apart from the clinical trials, advanced engineering cell reprocessing center must be available with good corroboration with the hospitals.

Since Japan made the Immuno-Cell Therapy to be a part of health care systems, the cell processing centers (CPCs) rapidly increased in the past decades. For the therapy of high complexity such as dendritic cell / autologous enhancement immunotherapy to be regularly practiced in the hospital, those CPCs were essential, and this explains why much of innovations in cell based cancer immunotherapy took place in Japan. 

Endoscopic Submucosal Dissection (ESD) \ Endoscopic Mucosal Resection (EMR) in Japan

Both EMR and ESD was originally developed in Japan. EMR / ESD (endoscopic biopsy or polyp resection procedure on gastrointestinal tract) is the area that Japanese surgeons are leading the research at forefront. It is the minimally invasive endoscopic procedure that conserves organs / tissues, and patients can be discharged from the hospital in the same day or a week after the operations. It is usually applicable to early stage cancer / tumor, and improves the post-surgical health conditions such as loss of appetite, fever, chills, pains and life-long medication.

Proton Beam Therapy

Currently there are about 31 proton (or carbon ion) therapy facilities in the world, 8 of which is built in Japan. Proton Beam Therapy is much less invasive than other radiotherapy treatments, and can treat the cancer without incision of the body, and with much less side effects than X-ray treatments. Japan has invested in Proton beam therapy (PBT) / Carbon Ion Therapy infrastructure for a long time, and clinical level studies are numerous and thus well experienced with all kinds of localized tumors.

Radiofrequency Ablation (RFA) on Liver cancer (Hepatocellular carcinoma)

Japan has been leading the RFA intervention technology for a long time, and the yearly number of RFA interventions in Japan currently exceeds that of United States and China. (See the Table below.) Survival rates for the patients undergoing the RFA are not different from those of surgery. But the surgery is harder to be operated multiple times, whereas the RFA is not restricted by the number of interventions or by the presence of Hepatitis.  For this reason, RFA becomes a standard treatment in Japan.

Yearly volume of RFA on Liver Cancer
Japan 34,000
US 14,000
China 9,500

Table: Yearly number of Radiofrequency ablation of Liver or hepatic tumors by country.

Regenerative Medicine on Dilated Cardiomyopathy, or Myocardial Infarction

Recent technological advances in cell sheets engineering extended to the pre-clinical trial of the treatment of heart disease patients often in need for the heart transplant.

Micro-Catheter treatments on varicose veins (including the veins below the knee)

In japan, complex operations towards varicose veins below the knee are established with safey and high response rates. Various catheter and micro-catheter devices are extensively used, and some of them are only available in Japan.

Cancer and Heart Disease Treatment in Japan  

Medical technology in Japan for cancer screening and gastrointestinal diseases are known to be very strong, supported by good clinical statistics, i.e., high five year survival rate after the surgery (or radiology / chemotherapy) among the colon, rectal, stomach, and esophageal cancer patients as well as liver, lung, and larynx cancer (See Table below). 

Since Japanese health agency is notoriously slow and counter-productive when it comes to the approval of new drugs, Japan's hospitals and patients suffered for so long by the technology lag from the rest of the world. Ironically, these regulatory problems lead physicians to the innovations in the fields other than drug discoveries, i.e., in the surgical / laparoscopic, endoscopic, micro-catheter procedures, cell based immunotherapy / vaccinations, radiation (carbon ion and proton beam), and regenerative medicine (iPS cells, cell sheets).

Since the Japanese physicians had less options in chemotherapy, they had more opportunities in experiencing difficult surgeries, and tried the new treatments due to the low availability of new drugs. Thus, many exotic and unique medical technologies emerged out of the isolations casued by the incompetence of Japanese health agency.

Site (Survival Rate:  %)

7 Cancer Registrates in Japan

US SEER Program Eurocare-3
Esophagus 25 14 10
Stomach 58 22 23
Colon 66 62 51
Rectum 63 63 48
Liver 17 7 7
Gallbladder 18 16 12
Pancreas 6 4 4
Larynx 77 65 62
Lung, bronchus 20 15 11